How Do I know the Value of my Coins ?

It’s hard to know the value of a coin sight-unseen by one of our numismatists. With coins even the smallest characteristics or factors may significantly affect value. For this reason, one of our numismatists must see the piece or collection to provide an accurate appraisal.

You may obtain a general idea of a coin’s potential value, as well as learning its mintage and some historical detail, by referring to The Official Red Book, a Whitman publication.

This reference source, updated annually, can typically be found in local libraries; you may also purchase it from local book stores.

Should I clean my coin?

We don’t recommend cleaning coins. Even the gentlest attempt to clean a coin will likely damage the surface and/or change the color of the metal, most often seriously affecting its value. Although the damage or change may not seem apparent, a trained numismatist or knowledgeable collector will be able detect the cleaning.

Where can I get my coins and/or currency certified?

There are several grading services where you can have your coins/currency certified. BTC is an authorized dealer with all the major grading companies and you can have your coins/currency certified through us. We will help you screen your coins/currency and select the appropriate submission tiers, package your coins/currency for safe shipment, and assist in determining insurance values so that they’re protected against loss in shipping. Alternatively, you can choose to pay for a membership with one of the grading services which allows you to send your coins/currency directly to them for certification.

Why should I have my coin/currency certified?

In some cases, the grading fees involved will make certification an impractical choice. However, as long as the value of your coin supports it, there can be several benefits to a third-party certification. In addition to confirming the authenticity of the piece, a professional numismatist will be able to accurately determine its grade or condition using recognized industry standards. Though some grading inconsistencies are unavoidable, since personal judgment is still a factor, experienced coin collectors will have greater confidence in the professionally certified grade—most often giving your coin or currency greater value.

How should I store my coin collection?

There are several different types of books and holders that will serve well for coin storage- look for some of the better types offering greater protection against surface discoloration. Avoid types of holders using staples, which can easily scratch your coins. Currency should always be stored flat in acid-free or archival-type holders. Finally, be sure to store your collection in a dry environment.

Buying and Selling

Does Big Thicket Coin buy coins?

BTC does buy coins. Preliminarily, we’ll ask you to provide as much information as possible about your coin(s) including: date, denomination, mintmark and, if applicable, grading service and grade. We’ll also ask you to email pictures. That information will allow us to give you an estimate of the price we would pay, but we won’t be able to provide a firm offer until we examine the coin(s) in hand. If our preliminary offer is acceptable to you, we’ll ask you to ship the coin(s) to us, including a packing list detailing the items enclosed and providing your name, address, and telephone number.

We’ll contact you when the shipment is received and will let you know at that time, how long our evaluation will take (typically 3-5 business days, though larger collections may take longer).

Does BTC accept trades?

BTC is always willing to consider trades. Please refer to the terms outlined in the previous topic, “Does BTC buy coins?” for details regarding the process.

My Account

How does the Want List Manager work?

Simply log in to your account and go to your Want List Manager. Select the appropriate choices from each of the drop-down categories and the item will be added to your Want List. We’ll send you an email when a matching item becomes available in our inventory.

What is BTC’s Privacy Policy?

When ordering or registering on our site, you will be asked to enter your name and email address. You may, however, visit our site anonymously. The information we collect from you may be used to personalize your experience with us, improve our website, improve customer service, process transactions and to send periodic emails (Please note: If, at any time, you would like to unsubscribe from receiving future emails, we include unsubscribe instructions at the bottom of each email)

We do not sell, trade, or otherwise transfer to outside parties your personally identifiable information. This does not include trusted third parties assisting us in operating our website, conducting our business, or servicing you, so long as those parties agree to keep this information confidential. We may also release your information when we believe release is appropriate to comply with the law, enforce our site policies or protect ours or other rights, property, or safety.

Ordering on

What payment methods does BTC accept?

BTC accepts personal checks, bank or cashier checks*, PayPal, Visa, Amex, Discover and MasterCard. We also accept Bank Wires- just contact us for Wire Transfer instructions. *Please note: We cannot accept credit card/convenience checks.

Does BTC ship internationally?

BTC ships to U.S. addresses, Puerto Rico, Guam and APO addresses. Due to the large number of losses and delays we experienced when shipping outside of the U.S., we no longer ship internationally.

What method of shipping is used? Is shipping always free?

Orders of $2000 or more will be shipped via USPS Priority Express mail, all others are shipped by USPS First Class mail. All shipments are insured, and most will require a signature for delivery. BTC offers free shipping on all orders; if you choose to upgrade to Priority Express for an order that would not otherwise quality for expedited shipping, a reasonable fee will be charged, as noted on your order page.

Can I have an order shipped to an address other than my billing address?

For your protection and ours, we’re not able to ship to an address other than your billing address.

What are the Terms and Conditions of Sale?

All sales are subject to product availability. While every precaution is taken to ensure accuracy in titles, descriptions and prices, errors may occur from time to time. In those cases, BTC reserves the right to make all necessary adjustments. Buyer will be contacted if an order contains any such inaccuracies.

Title to all merchandise shall remain with seller until payment has been received by seller. A check shall not constitute payment until said check has cleared through normal banking channels.

What is BTC Return Policy?

Items may be returned for credit or refund if postmarked within 14 days of receipt and only if not damaged or removed from original encapsulation. Please package all returns securely, including a copy of your invoice or other documentation identifying the shipment as a return, and insure the shipment; upon receipt, BTC will issue a refund within 2 business days.

What do I do if I need to change or cancel an order?

You can contact us to change or cancel an order at any time prior to its shipment.